Report Judge

An evidence-audit workbench showing uncertainty and claims requiring human review.

Audit each factual sentence separately. Orchard has a sourced retry limit and an unrelated deployment claim; one valid marker must not make the whole paragraph pass.

Start with a learner workspace

Retrieval augmented generation, Model evaluation, Verification gates. Language foundation: Python data structures.

Use Python 3.10+ and its standard library. POSIX is required where the project uses file locks or process-group supervision.

python3 scripts/project_test.py report-judge --init learning-artifacts/report-judge
python3 scripts/project_test.py report-judge --stage 1 --path learning-artifacts/report-judge

Build route

1. Parse claims and citation references
2. Check evidence before averaging scores
3. Report precision coverage and source recall
4. Compare paired revisions with bootstrap intervals

Run with your own inputs

After completing the stages, these commands run your workspace code on the original Orchard examples. Replace the sample paths with your own files.

python3 learning-artifacts/report-judge/cli.py projects/report-judge/examples/claims.json --out evidence-audit.json --html evidence-audit.html

To inspect the complete reference first, replace learning-artifacts/report-judge with projects/report-judge/solution in the same command. JSON results use schema_version: 1; paths and argument examples are explicit so another tool can consume them.

Integration boundary

The judge provides conservative lexical evidence checks. Order, numbers and negation expose some false matches; paraphrases can still be rejected and other false matches remain. Missing recall/coverage labels are null. No automated score proves truth.

python3 scripts/project_test.py report-judge --all --solution --strict
python3 scripts/project_test.py report-judge --all --path learning-artifacts/report-judge --strict

The first command checks the reference. The second checks your implementation. The published examples and tests are regression evidence, not a production certification or an unseen benchmark.